{"schema_version":"0.1","map_id":"paper-77-map","publication_id":77,"publication_anchor":"paper-77","slug":"paper-77","canonical_path":"/knowledge/papers/paper-77/","machine_path":"/knowledge/papers/paper-77.json","root_node_id":"paper-77","stage":"mapped_draft","contribution_type_vocabulary_version":"0.1","contribution_types":[],"title":"Towards Further Realizing Random Oracles: Post-Quantum Non-Malleable Point Obfuscation","short_title":"Post-Quantum Non-Malleable Point Obfuscation","year":null,"venue":null,"publication_status":"Ongoing work","topic":"algorithms-foundations","labels":["Theory"],"availability":"Public manuscript not found; this work is listed as ongoing.","authors":["Daniel Apon","Chongwon Cho","Karim Eldefrawy","Feng-Hao Liu","Rafail Ostrovsky"],"keywords":["post-quantum cryptography","obfuscation"],"research_question":"Can a post-quantum point-function obfuscation notion resist malleation while reproducing a useful aspect of random-oracle behavior?","central_answer":"The title establishes this research objective, and a NIST administrative email verifies that a manuscript with this title and author list entered an internal review process in 2021. No public manuscript was located, so the construction, security notion, quantum-access model, assumptions, theorem, and proof remain unaudited.","curation":{"drafted_at":"2026-07-11","drafted_by":[{"actor_type":"ai","name":"OpenAI Codex","role":"metadata verification, administrative-provenance analysis, public-source searching, and uncertainty documentation"}],"method":"AI drafting from the author-site record, a public NIST administrative email, and exact-title, author-title, archive, index, and coauthor-profile searches. The NIST document is used only as manuscript provenance; it is not treated as full text, peer review, a citation, or evidence for any technical claim.","source_scope":"metadata_administrative_provenance_and_documented_public_source_search","approval":{"status":"pending","note":"AI-authored bounded map awaiting full author audit; technical content is intentionally not reconstructed from the title alone."}},"sources":[{"id":"source-paper-77-curated","type":"curated_site_record","title":"Website publication record for Paper #77","url":"/publications/#paper-77","scope_note":"Author-site title, authorship, ongoing-work status, and editorial summary; not a manuscript or technical source."},{"id":"source-paper-77-nist-email","type":"administrative_provenance_record","title":"NIST ERB sponsor-review email mentioning the manuscript","url":"https://nist.pqcrypto.org/foia/20250416/RE_%20NPS_%20REMINDER%20-%20ERB%20Sponsor%20Review%20Manuscript.pdf","media_type":"application/pdf","scope_note":"The email names the manuscript and authors, records a 2021-03-02 submission date and ERB Control G2021-0620, and discusses administrative sponsor review before intended conference submission. It is neither the manuscript nor a scholarly citation, venue decision, review report, or technical validation."},{"id":"source-paper-77-manuscript-search","type":"source_search_record","title":"Public-manuscript search for Paper #77","url":"https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Towards+Further+Realizing+Random+Oracles%3A+Post-Quantum+Non-Malleable+Point+Obfuscation%22","accessed_at":"2026-07-11","scope_note":"Exact-title and author-title variants were checked across the open web, IACR ePrint, arXiv, DBLP, Crossref, OpenAlex, NIST/public-record pages, and discoverable author or coauthor pages. The NIST email was located, but no public manuscript, abstract, DOI, ePrint identifier, venue paper page, or stable scholarly index record was found."},{"id":"source-paper-77-citation-search","type":"citation_search_snapshot","title":"Exact-title scholarly-web citation search","url":"https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Towards+Further+Realizing+Random+Oracles%3A+Post-Quantum+Non-Malleable+Point+Obfuscation%22","accessed_at":"2026-07-11","scope_note":"The NIST administrative email was excluded from reception because it does not cite the work as scholarship."}],"source_anchors":[{"id":"anchor-paper-77-metadata","source_id":"source-paper-77-curated","label":"Author-site paper metadata","locator":"Paper #77 title, named authors, topic, Theory label, and Ongoing work status","url":"/publications/#paper-77"},{"id":"anchor-paper-77-nist-email","source_id":"source-paper-77-nist-email","label":"NIST administrative manuscript provenance","locator":"Public email record naming the manuscript and five authors; submitted 2021-03-02 under ERB Control G2021-0620; administrative sponsor-review correspondence, not manuscript content or scholarly review","url":"https://nist.pqcrypto.org/foia/20250416/RE_%20NPS_%20REMINDER%20-%20ERB%20Sponsor%20Review%20Manuscript.pdf"},{"id":"anchor-paper-77-search-gap","source_id":"source-paper-77-manuscript-search","label":"Documented full-text search gap","locator":"Search completed 2026-07-11 across exact-title and author-title web queries, IACR ePrint, arXiv, DBLP, Crossref, OpenAlex, NIST records, and discoverable author/coauthor pages; administrative provenance found but no primary full text or stable scholarly record","url":"https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Towards+Further+Realizing+Random+Oracles%3A+Post-Quantum+Non-Malleable+Point+Obfuscation%22"},{"id":"anchor-paper-77-citations","source_id":"source-paper-77-citation-search","label":"Dated exact-title citation search","locator":"No citing scholarly work verifiably located; the NIST administrative email was excluded from the count","url":"https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Towards+Further+Realizing+Random+Oracles%3A+Post-Quantum+Non-Malleable+Point+Obfuscation%22"}],"nodes":[{"id":"paper-77","kind":"paper","parent_id":null,"order":1,"epistemic_status":"metadata_and_administrative_provenance_pending_author_audit","title":"Post-quantum non-malleable point obfuscation","summary":"An ongoing theory project whose title targets a post-quantum, non-malleable point-obfuscation primitive. A NIST email verifies manuscript identity and administrative history, but no technical text is public in the located sources.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-nist-email","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-question","kind":"question","parent_id":"paper-77","order":1,"epistemic_status":"title_inferred","title":"Research direction","summary":"Can point-function obfuscation retain a non-malleability property against quantum-capable adversaries and thereby realize a useful random-oracle-like capability?","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata"]},{"id":"paper-77-point-obfuscation","kind":"primitive","parent_id":"paper-77","order":2,"epistemic_status":"primitive_named_definition_unavailable","title":"Point obfuscation","summary":"Point obfuscation is named in the title. The point-function domain, correctness condition, hiding notion, auxiliary input, reusable access, and output representation are not specified publicly.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-nonmalleability","kind":"security_property","parent_id":"paper-77","order":3,"epistemic_status":"property_named_definition_unavailable","title":"Non-malleability target","summary":"Non-malleability is explicit in the title, but the admissible relation, challenge game, adversarial output, success event, and handling of trivial transformations are unavailable.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-postquantum","kind":"threat_model","parent_id":"paper-77","order":4,"epistemic_status":"adversary_class_named_model_unavailable","title":"Post-quantum adversary","summary":"The title claims a post-quantum setting, but it does not disclose whether the model permits quantum advice, superposition access, quantum random-oracle queries, adaptive challenge selection, or quantum outputs.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-random-oracle-goal","kind":"objective","parent_id":"paper-77","order":5,"epistemic_status":"objective_named_scope_unavailable","title":"Further realizing random oracles","summary":"The title situates the work in a program of realizing random-oracle behavior, but the targeted functionality, application class, and sense of realization cannot be inferred safely without the manuscript.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-construction","kind":"construction","parent_id":"paper-77","order":6,"epistemic_status":"not_available_for_audit","title":"Construction unavailable","summary":"No algorithm, compiler, parameter set, underlying primitive, or post-quantum assumption can be extracted from the located records.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-theorem","kind":"theorem_group","parent_id":"paper-77","order":7,"epistemic_status":"not_available_for_audit","title":"Theorem and proof unavailable","summary":"The available records do not establish existence, correctness, security, efficiency, or any reduction to a named hardness assumption.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-nist-provenance","kind":"provenance","parent_id":"paper-77","order":8,"epistemic_status":"administratively_documented","title":"NIST ERB record","summary":"A NIST email records that a manuscript with this title and author list was submitted on March 2, 2021 under ERB Control G2021-0620 and discusses sponsor review before intended conference peer review.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email"]},{"id":"paper-77-provenance-boundary","kind":"limitation","parent_id":"paper-77-nist-provenance","order":1,"epistemic_status":"source_scope_boundary","title":"What the email does not establish","summary":"The email does not provide the manuscript, theorem statements, proof, public release, venue submission identity, acceptance decision, reviewer judgment, or citation evidence.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email"]},{"id":"paper-77-evidence","kind":"evidence_group","parent_id":"paper-77","order":9,"epistemic_status":"no_public_technical_evidence_located","title":"Evidence status","summary":"No public proof, formalization, implementation, experiment, or supplementary artifact attributable to this paper was located.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-unknowns","kind":"limitation_group","parent_id":"paper-77","order":10,"epistemic_status":"explicit_unknowns","title":"Information needed for a substantive map","summary":"Manuscript audit must establish the point-obfuscation syntax, correctness and non-malleability games, quantum oracle-access model, assumptions, construction, reduction, parameter loss, efficiency, applications, and relation to prior random-oracle realizations.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-search","kind":"audit_record","parent_id":"paper-77","order":11,"epistemic_status":"documented_search","title":"Public-source search","summary":"Exact-title, author-title, archive, index, NIST-record, and public-profile searches located administrative provenance but no primary technical source; the provenance record was kept separate from evidence and reception.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"paper-77-artifacts","kind":"artifact_group","parent_id":"paper-77","order":12,"epistemic_status":"metadata_and_administrative_record_only","title":"Available artifacts","summary":"The represented resources are an author-site listing and a NIST administrative email; neither is the manuscript or a technical artifact.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-nist-email"]},{"id":"paper-77-scrutiny","kind":"scrutiny","parent_id":"paper-77","order":13,"epistemic_status":"no_completed_scholarly_scrutiny_located","title":"Scrutiny and reception","summary":"Administrative sponsor review is provenance, not completed scholarly peer review. No venue outcome, public review, reproduction, correction, cryptanalysis, or scholarly citation was located.","source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email","anchor-paper-77-citations"]}],"relations":[{"id":"paper-77-relation-question-point","type":"concerns","from_id":"paper-77-question","to_id":"paper-77-point-obfuscation"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-nonmalleability-qualifies-point","type":"constrains","from_id":"paper-77-nonmalleability","to_id":"paper-77-point-obfuscation"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-postquantum-qualifies-nonmalleability","type":"qualifies","from_id":"paper-77-postquantum","to_id":"paper-77-nonmalleability"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-point-targets-random-oracle-goal","type":"intended_to_support","from_id":"paper-77-point-obfuscation","to_id":"paper-77-random-oracle-goal"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-construction-would-realize-point","type":"would_realize","from_id":"paper-77-construction","to_id":"paper-77-point-obfuscation"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-theorem-would-support-construction","type":"would_support","from_id":"paper-77-theorem","to_id":"paper-77-construction"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-nist-contextualizes-paper","type":"establishes_provenance_for","from_id":"paper-77-nist-provenance","to_id":"paper-77"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-provenance-boundary-qualifies-nist","type":"qualifies","from_id":"paper-77-provenance-boundary","to_id":"paper-77-nist-provenance"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-search-limits-evidence","type":"limits_audit_of","from_id":"paper-77-search","to_id":"paper-77-evidence"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-unknowns-qualify-paper","type":"qualifies","from_id":"paper-77-unknowns","to_id":"paper-77"},{"id":"paper-77-relation-scrutiny-contextualizes-paper","type":"contextualizes","from_id":"paper-77-scrutiny","to_id":"paper-77"}],"assessment":{"id":"paper-77-assessment-2026-07-11","rubric_version":"0.2","assessed_at":"2026-07-11","status":"ai_draft_author_review_pending","note":"These dimensions describe documented support and process, not truth, correctness, or a universal ranking. No composite score is calculated.","axes":[{"id":"epistemic_evidence","level":"low","rationale":"The title and NIST email establish identity, objective, and administrative history, but no manuscript, definition, construction, theorem, proof, or technical artifact was located.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-nist-email","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"auditability","level":"low","rationale":"No paper-specific public archive or author-hosted manuscript was located. The NIST email is inspectable provenance but does not expose assumptions, evidence, or version content.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]},{"id":"production_provenance","level":"medium","rationale":"Named authorship, ongoing-work status, submission date, and ERB control number provide a concrete human and lifecycle trail. Contributor roles, revisions, AI or tool use, and manuscript/artifact lineage remain unaudited.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-nist-email"]},{"id":"external_scrutiny","level":"low","rationale":"The located record documents administrative sponsor review and intended later conference review, not a completed scholarly review outcome or independent technical validation.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-nist-email"]},{"id":"reception","level":"low","rationale":"The dated exact-title search located 0 scholarly citations. Under the author-defined rule, 0–8 located citations is Low, 9–10 is Medium, and 11 or more is High; the NIST email is provenance, not a citation.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-citations"]},{"id":"contribution_significance","level":"not_assessed","rationale":"The title describes an ambitious theoretical objective, but result strength, novelty, assumptions, and impact cannot be assessed without technical text.","basis_source_anchor_ids":["anchor-paper-77-metadata","anchor-paper-77-search-gap"]}]},"reception_snapshot":{"as_of":"2026-07-11","method":"Exact-title scholarly-web search with administrative mentions excluded","citation_count":0,"source_url":"https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Towards+Further+Realizing+Random+Oracles%3A+Post-Quantum+Non-Malleable+Point+Obfuscation%22","signals":[],"limitation":"No public manuscript or stable index record was located. Zero means no scholarly citation was verifiably attributable to the exact title; the NIST email establishes manuscript provenance only."}}